How Should Brands Measure a Creator Campaign?
Measure a creator campaign against the one goal you set before it started, using numbers you can trace to each creator: tracked clicks, orders, codes used and cost per sale for a sales goal, or saves, shares and comments for an awareness goal. Follower counts and likes are a starting point, not a result. A creator with a small audience that trusts them can sell more than one with a large audience that scrolls past. This guide covers which numbers matter for each goal, how to track them, how to compare creators fairly and what to report after the campaign.
What Should You Decide Before the Campaign Starts?
Decide what the campaign is for. Most creator campaigns aim at one of three things:
- Sales: orders you can trace to a creator's link or code.
- Awareness: new people seeing and remembering your brand.
- Content: photos and videos you can reuse in your own ads, emails and pages.
A campaign can do all three, but you can only judge it against the one you chose first. If you planned for awareness and judge on sales, a good campaign looks like a failure. If you planned for sales and judge on likes, a weak one can look like a success.
Write the goal into your brief, along with the numbers you will look at and when. Our guide on how brands should brief Black creators for holiday campaigns shows where that fits in a brief.
Which Numbers Matter for a Sales Campaign?
For sales, measure what each creator actually caused:
- Clicks: how many people tapped the creator's tracked link.
- Orders: how many orders came through that link or the creator's code.
- Conversion rate: orders divided by clicks, which shows whether the audience was ready to buy.
- Revenue: the value of those orders, after returns.
- Cost per sale: what you paid the creator, in fees, commission and free product, divided by the orders they drove.
- New customers: how many of those buyers had never ordered from you before.
An example of the math, not a promise: if you pay a creator a $300 fee plus 10% commission, and their link and code bring 40 orders at $60 each, you pay $300 plus $240, which is $540. That is $13.50 per order on $2,400 in sales. Compare that with what an order costs you through your other channels.
Count codes as well as links. Shoppers who watch a video often type a code instead of tapping a link, and on some setups only the code credits the sale. Our guide on whether affiliates should get discount codes, links or both explains why.
Which Numbers Matter for an Awareness Campaign?
For awareness, look at signs that people paid attention rather than only scrolled past:
- Saves and shares: people keeping the post or sending it to someone, which is a stronger signal than a like.
- Comments: especially questions about the product, which show real interest.
- Reach among new people: creators can share their post insights with you, including how many accounts saw it.
- Branded search and direct visits: whether more people searched your name or typed your web address during the campaign.
- Follower growth on your own accounts: people who liked what they saw enough to follow you.
Ask creators for screenshots of their post insights in your brief, so you get the numbers only they can see. Agree the date they will send them, such as seven days after the post goes live.
How Do You Judge Content You Plan to Reuse?
If part of the goal is content, judge each piece on how well it works in your own channels. Run the creator's video as an ad or put their photos on a product page, then compare the results with your own content.
Agree the rights first. Your contract should say where you can use the content, for how long and whether paid ads are included. Content you cannot legally reuse has no value to this goal, however good it looks.
How Do You Compare Creators Fairly?
Raw totals favor the biggest accounts. Use rates instead, so a creator with a smaller audience gets a fair test:
- Orders per thousand followers, or per thousand views of the post.
- Cost per sale, rather than total sales.
- Saves and shares per thousand views, rather than total likes.
Judge each creator over more than one post where you can. One post can land on a slow day or a busy news cycle. Two or three posts give a fairer picture of what an audience will do.
Look at who the new customers are, too. If a creator brings you buyers you were not reaching before, that is worth more than sales from people who already knew you.
What Mistakes Make Creator Results Look Better or Worse Than They Are?
- Judging on followers or likes alone, which says little about sales.
- Counting a sale twice when a shopper used one creator's code after tapping another creator's link. Decide in your terms which one gets the credit.
- Ignoring returns. An order that comes back is not a sale.
- Stopping the count too early. Some shoppers buy days after they see a post, within the program's tracking window.
- Leaving out free product and shipping when you add up what a creator cost.
- Letting a shared code leak to coupon sites, which credits a creator for sales they did not cause.
What Should a Campaign Report Include?
Keep it to one page so it gets read:
- The goal you set and whether you met it.
- Each creator's results, using rates as well as totals.
- What you paid each creator in total, including product.
- The best piece of content and why it worked.
- Who you will work with again, and what you will change next time.
Share the parts that concern each creator with them. Creators who know what worked can do more of it, and a brand that shares results is one creators want to work with again. If you want to keep the creators who perform, see what a brand is responsible for when creators promote it so every post stays compliant as the program grows.
Afrofiliate is an affiliate network built for Black-owned businesses and the brands that want to reach Black consumers, with tracked links and codes for every creator and a dashboard that shows every click and sale. Find Black creators to promote you on Afrofiliate and see what each one drives.